Breaking news: Obama forms task force to speed CCS

February 3, 2010 by Ken Ward Jr.


IMPORTANT UPDATES … See below for President’s announcement

President Obama is set to meet in about a half-hour with about a dozen governors from key energy-producing states, including West Virginia Gov. Joe Manchin.

My sources tell me to expect the president to announce the formation of a new task force aimed at speeding up the development and deployment of carbon capture and storage technology for coal-fired and other fossil fuel power plants. The task force would be chaired by the Department of Energy and the Environmental Protection Agency.

Two months ago, the Obama administration’s Department of Energy announced it was pumping $334 million in federal stimulus dollars into American Electric Power’s CCS project at the Mountaineer Power Plant in Mason County, W.Va.  And in his budget proposal submitted to Congress earlier this week, Obama proposed $545 million for development of CCS technologies.

Of course, there are many questions and challenges facing CCS, but many experts believe it’s the coal industry’s best chance to survive limits on greenhouse gases.


Here’s a link to the president’s announcement on CCS:

For decades, the coal industry has supported quality high-paying jobs for American workers, and coal has provided an important domestic source of reliable, affordable energy.  At the same time, coal-fired power plants are the largest contributor to U.S. greenhouse gas emissions and coal accounts for 40 percent of global emissions.  Charting a path toward clean coal is essential to achieving my Administration’s goals of providing clean energy, supporting American jobs, and reducing emissions of carbon pollution.  Rapid commercial development and deployment of clean coal technologies, particularly carbon capture and storage (CCS), will help position the United States as a leader in the global clean energy race.

To further this work and develop a comprehensive and coordinated Federal strategy to speed the commercial development and deployment of clean coal technologies, I hereby establish an Interagency Task Force on Carbon Capture and Storage (Task Force).  You shall each designate a senior official from your respective agency to serve on the Task Force, which shall be Co Chaired by the designees from the Department of Energy and the Environmental Protection Agency.

The Task Force shall develop within 180 days of the date of this memorandum a proposed plan to overcome the barriers to the widespread, cost-effective deployment of CCS within 10 years, with a goal of bringing 5 to 10 commercial demonstration projects online by 2016.  The plan should explore incentives for commercial CCS adoption and address any financial, economic, technological, legal, institutional, social, or other barriers to deployment.  The Task Force should consider how best to coordinate existing administrative authorities and programs, including those that build international collaboration on CCS, as well as identify areas where additional administrative authority may be necessary.  The Co Chairs shall report progress periodically to the President through the Chair of the Council on Environmental Quality.

And here’s some audio of a telephone press conference held this afternoon

And some audio of Gov. Manchin’s press call later in the afternoon

6 Responses to “Breaking news: Obama forms task force to speed CCS”

  1. Ken Ward Jr. says:

    here’s a statement from the National Mining Association:

    “News that the president will create a high-level task force on CCS technology is very welcome. It’s an acknowledgement by the administration not only of the importance of this technology for controlling global greenhouse gas emissions, but also of the vital role played by coal in supplying affordable electricity to America and a growing world economy.

    “There is widespread agreement among both private and public energy experts that reducing concentrations of greenhouse gas emissions without carbon capture and storage technology will be difficult, if not impossible. Coal has been the world’s fastest growing fuel in each of the past five years. Projected coal consumption in rapidly expanding economies such as China’s and India’s strongly suggests that greater public-sector support for CCS technology is imperative. Coal-based generation, which already supplies half of this country’s electricity, is essential to maintaining reliable and affordable electricity so America can continue to prosper in an increasingly competitive world.

    “U.S. mining is eager to cooperate with the task force in furthering the development and deployment of CCS and other advanced clean coal technologies.”

  2. Ken Ward Jr. says:

    Here’s a transcript released by the WH of what Obama said at the meeting:


    Office of the Press Secretary


    For Immediate Release February 3, 2010




    State Dining Room

    2:06 P.M. EST

    THE PRESIDENT: Well, listen, I just want to personally welcome all the governors who are here today. As I said at the State of the Union last week, I am convinced that whoever builds a clean energy economy, whoever is at the forefront of that, is going to own the 21st century global economy. Last year, we made the largest investment in clean energy in our history. It’s an investment that’s already leading to new jobs and new businesses across the country. You’ve got solar panel production in California. You got advanced batteries in North Carolina. Every state is starting to take advantage of a lot of what’s already been done.

    But if anybody read the story in The New York Times last Sunday, countries like China are moving even faster. And they’re very aggressive about wanting to make sure that these clean energy jobs are in their countries. As I said at the State of the Union, I’m not going to settle for a situation where the United States comes in second place or third place or fourth place in what will be the most important economic engine in the future.

    Now, there’s no reason that we shouldn’t be able to work together in a bipartisan way to get this done. I know that there is some concern about how energy fits together with climate change. I happen to believe that climate change is one of the reasons why we’ve got to pursue a clean energy agenda, but it’s not the only reason. So even if you don’t believe in the severity of climate change, as I do, you still should want to pursue this agenda. It’s good for our national security and reducing our dependence on foreign oil. It’s good for our economy because it will produce jobs.

    We can’t afford to spin our wheels while the rest of the world speeds ahead. And that’s why I’ve asked these governors — leaders in their own right and their states around energy issues, Democrats and Republicans –- to meet here today so that we can work through some of these challenges and opportunities that are presented by the transition to a clean energy economy.

    I want to be clear that my administration is following a non-ideological approach to this issue. We believe in a strategy of more production, more efficiency, and more incentives for clean energy. We’re willing to make some tough decisions on issues like offshore drilling, so long as we protect coastlines and communities. We are moving forward on a new generation of nuclear power plants, although we want to make sure that they are safe and secure.

    One of the things that we’re going to be talking about today is investing in the kind of technology that will allow us to use coal, our most bountiful natural resource here in the United States, without polluting our planet.

    It’s been said that the United States is the Saudi Arabia of coal –- and that’s because, as I said, it’s one of our most abundant energy resources. If we can develop the technology to capture the carbon pollution released by coal, it can create jobs and provide energy well into the future. So today I’m announcing a Carbon Capture and Storage Task Force that will be charged with the goal of figuring out how we can deploy affordable clean coal technology on a widespread scale within 10 years. And we want to get up 10 commercial demonstration projects, get those up and running by 2016.

    We’re also going to be talking about some developments we’re making on biofuels, so that more folks can start filling up their cars and trucks with cleaner, American-grown fuels. By 2022, we will more than double the amount of biofuels we produce to 36 billion gallons, which will decrease our dependence on foreign oil by hundreds of millions of barrels per year. We’re also working to make sure that we can start turning things like plants and woodchips into heat, power, and biofuels, and that will create new economic opportunities for rural communities. And our biofuels working group is releasing its first report that details the government’s strategy for supporting the biofuels industry.

    The bottom line is this: I am convinced that America can win the race to build a clean energy economy, but we’re going to have to overcome the weight of our own politics. We have to focus not so much on those narrow areas where we disagree, but on the broad areas where we agree.

    And I also think it’s important for us to understand that in order for us to move forward with a robust energy policy, we’ve got to have not an either/or philosophy but a both/and philosophy — a philosophy that says traditional sources of energy are going to continue to be important for a while so we’ve got to just use technologies to make them cleaner and more efficient; that we’re going to have to pursue an energy-efficiency agenda across our economy.

    We’re going to also have to develop new sources of energy that allow us to take advantage of sun, wind, our coastlines, and in ways that over time can actually enhance our standards of living, create jobs, and also protect our environment.

    That’s the agenda I want to pursue. I am confident that’s the agenda that these governors want to pursue as well. And so I’m grateful to have them here and I’m looking forward to hearing their ideas.

    I should point out, obviously, that we also have our key Cabinet members here — Steven Chu, Tom Vilsack, Ken Salazar, Lisa Jackson — who are here as well, and Nancy Sutley at our Council of Environmental Quality, and Carol Browner, who’s doing a lot of our coordination in the White House, so that we’ve got our top people on energy and the environment in the room to have this discussion.

    Now, with that, I want to give Joe just a brief chance to speak.

    THE VICE PRESIDENT: Mr. President, let me just add a few points. By the way, welcome. These poor guys, Mr. President, and women have had to listen to me on telephone calls on the Recovery Act over the last several months. I thank you for your cooperation. It’s been — I hope we’ve been responsive.

    Well, look, the announcement you’re making today, Mr. President, builds on an unprecedented investment that the federal government has made, in large part through the Recovery Act, to deal with investments in clean energy and lessen our dependence on foreign oil — $80 billion. That has leveraged another $70 billion, Mr. President, for a total investment of $150 billion in clean energy. A little more than a third of that money is out the door, and it’s already saved and created somewhere in the area of over 10,000 jobs, to go to your point about it’s not just about the environment; this is a job creator.

    That includes more than $3 billion in clean coal projects for West Virginia — from West Virginia to Alabama, and $600 million in biofuels, which are on track now, Mr. President, will be placed in various states across the country here.

    We’re now on track to go from zero — zero commercial-scale biofuel refineries to 19 by the year 2012, and from no commercial-scale power plants operating carbon capture to five by the year 2015.

    We’re putting this economy, through these governors, Mr. President, and putting this country on track to lead the world in clean coal technology which we can export — including exporting to China, which China is building coal-powered plants at a rate of one per month — one per month. And they need this technology to capture their emissions.

    And overall, I’ve learned through my regular calls with all these governors, Mr. President, the best way to make the Recovery Act work for everyone is to hear from everyone, and they’ve made significant input to how we’ve managed the Recovery Act.

    Again, I want to end my brief comment by thanking them and welcoming them here to the White House. And I think we have a chance to — there used to be a Lawton Chiles, he used to be a governor, and a senator I worked with for years, and Lawton once said one day, I said, Mr. President, I said, “Lawton, why are you so excited about that bill we passed?” And I thought I missed the significance, it wasn’t that big of a deal. He said, “Joe, it’s so seldom in American politics when conscience and convenience cross paths, you should celebrate.” (Laughter.) This is a place where conscience and convenience cross paths.

    THE PRESIDENT: Let’s get it done. Thank you very much, everybody.

  3. Ken Ward Jr. says:

    here’s a comment from the Sierra Club:

    “While we stand wholeheartedly behind President Obama’s overall vision, there are some areas of disagreement. We believe that there is no such thing as ‘clean coal.’ While further research into carbon capture and sequestration technology may ultimately prove useful and economically feasible for existing facilities, we do not support building new coal plants using a costly and unproven technology that even the coal industry itself refuses to expend its own resources on to commercialize. And while nuclear power and offshore drilling may be necessary to win a few votes in the Senate, they don’t do anything to help us transition to the clean energy future. Any legislation, especially when taxpayer dollars are being spent, needs to prioritize the cleanest, cheapest, fastest, and safest means of reducing emissions. As the president himself said this morning, ‘one of the best ways to be on the forefront in energy is to incentivize clean energy, and discourage the old sources or methods that aren’t going to work in the future.’ We believe coal, nuclear power, and more offshore drilling are all things that are not going to work in the clean energy future.

  4. roselle says:

    Considering the cost of retrofitting old coal fired power plants and building new CCS power plants the amount of money the President has offered is a mere drop in the bucket. He doesn’t want to sound unreasonable, but it doesn’t look to me like he believes in the wisdom of actually increasing the amount of coal we mine to produce electricity. Otherwise would we be seeing billions, not millions, of dollars committed?

  5. […] For a full transcript of the governors meeting, check out Ken Wards blog on Coal Tattoo. […]

  6. Ken Ward Jr. says:

    FYI everybody … here’s the prepared statement Gov. Manchin issued:

    “I want to thank the president and vice president and the environmental officials for their time today. We had a very open dialogue unlike anything I’ve participated in at this level. I had the opportunity to ask everything and say everything that is on my mind with regard to our energy future. I shared with them that in West Virginia, we care about the environment, but also the security of our nation, energy independence and the economy and the jobs that go with that.

    “The discussion from all the governors present was very frank, and I think the president took it in and I think the administration has a better idea of where we are coming from.

    “From West Virginia’s standpoint, I don’t think the administration realized the efforts we’ve undertaken to diversify our energy portfolio and use our natural resources in more environmentally friendly ways, as we make the transition to the energy fuels of the future. Those programs include our alternative and renewable energy portfolio act and our post-mine land use bill.

    “I am encouraged about our discussion of more investment in technology that will allow us to use our coal in more environmentally friendly ways and I support the president’s establishment of an Interagency Task Force on Carbon Capture and Storage that I hope will speed the development and use of clean coal technologies.

    “Overall, I’m very pleased with the candid discussion we had today and I think through continued dialogue like this, we will have a better understanding and be able to accomplish many of the shared goals with regard to our state’s and our nation’s energy future.”

Leave a Reply